Missing Hiring Steps? You Might be Overlooking Star Candidates

Published: 19 April 2017
Updated: 20 March 2025

Table of Contents

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Receive updates on trends and insights to build the best team at your company today.

From current employees covering for open roles to missed revenue opportunities – such as when you’re short a sales person – productivity is disrupted each time a business has an open position. To get business back on track, HR managers and business owners often want to fill open positions as soon as possible. But while quick and efficient hiring is ideal it’s also important to avoid missing steps in the hiring process. By skipping steps, not only do you risk making a bad hire, but you could also overlook strong candidates.
Following are several steps you should take each time you make a new hire – even if you’re in a hurry to get your next employee on board:

Regularly Review Applicants

Whether you’re a business owner, HR leader or hiring manager, you likely have a busy schedule – so you might find it easier to set aside time once or twice a week to review applicants. However, Hireology research has shown that applicants reviewed and acted upon quickly are more likely to be hired. Across Hireology customers using our integrated process, 70 percent of new hires are reviewed within 12 hours of submitting an application. Responding to applicants daily can help ensure strong candidates stay excited about the the possibility of working for your business. If you leave applicants waiting around for a response, you risk losing qualified candidates to other job opportunities – and even your competitors.

Review All Applicants

In an effort to speed up hiring, you might be tempted to interview and hire one of the first strong applicants that stands out. But if you don’t review all applicants, top candidates can slip through the cracks. Using an efficient, consistent hiring process can help you track the percentage of applicants each location or manager reviews – and hold them accountable for improving. In the long run, this will ensure you don’t overlook any top candidates and, ultimately, hire your best team.

Schedule Multiple Interviews

Even if a candidate aces an interview, it’s still important to schedule multiple rounds of interviews – and do so with several candidates. The best approach is typically to start with a phone screen before inviting candidates for an in-person interview. This can save time on both ends and help you weed out candidates who either don’t seem like a fit or don’t actually seem interested in working for your company – and learn more about strong candidates. When scheduling in-person interviews, move the process along as quickly as possible, as a delay in this step poses another risk for losing strong candidates to competing jobs.

Administer Skills Assessments

Not all positions require skills that can easily be tested, but for some roles, skills assessments are critical to ensuring you don’t make a bad hire. Data shows up to 56 percent of job applicants lie on their resumes, so skills assessments can confirm whether or not candidates have the skills to be successful at your company. For example, a candidate might say he or she is an expert in Excel and a skills assessment can verify this claim – or prove otherwise. If it turns out a candidate doesn’t have the skills he or she claims, you can move forward with a more qualified candidate you might have otherwise missed.

Complete Background And Reference Checks

Beyond skills assessments, background and reference checks confirm each candidate is who they say they claim to be on paper. Reference checks in particular can help serve as a final step to ensure you’re making a great hire. If a reference says something along the lines of not wanting to work with the candidate again, it’s a red flag that means you should move forward with another candidate as you finalize your hiring.
Hireology’s proven hiring process helps retail automotive and franchise businesses, among others, complete every step of the hiring process and hire their best teams. Interested in learning more about your time to hire and whether or not you locations and managers are completing your hiring process? This data will soon be available with Hireology’s new Insights capabilities, set to be released in a few weeks. Insights will enable our customers to compare their performance in various steps of the hiring process against industry benchmarks, and identify key areas for improvement.
 

Interested in learning more about how to improve your hiring?

Download our eBook, “The 9 Elements Of A Well-Oiled Hiring Process.”

Ready to Experience Hiring Built for You?

Concise statement goes here in this location lorem ipsum.

Keep Reading

Business man at computer

Hiring Metrics That Matter: How to Track What Drives Revenue and Profitability

Read More

The Real Cost of Unfilled Positions in Long-Term Care: Fill Roles Faster with Hireology

Read More
Two professionals shaking hands

3 Hiring Process Takeaways From the Field: Insights for Senior Care

Read More
Attract & Source
A diversified strategy helps find and attract the right people faster, while building a pipeline of qualified candidates for every role.
Features:
Job Boards
New
Career Sites
AI
Referrals
QR Codes
Campaigns
Engage & Evaluate
Leading-edge tools enhance candidate experience, and help teams to connect, dig deeper, and assess with consistency.
Features:
SMS
New
Email
AI
AI / Automation
Prescreen Survey
Interview Scheduling
Decision & Hiring
Hireology helps to get hiring to the top of the to-do list with real-time prompts and reminders that can be accessed and acted upon from a mobile device.
Features:
Background Check
New
Offer Letter
AI
References
Testing
Interview Guides
Manage & Optimize
Transformative tools drive next-level hiring solutions which align teams, sharpen focus on priorities, and drive growth.
Features:
Action Center
New
Collaboration Tools
AI
Reqs & Approvals
Mobile App
Onboarding
Selection Manager
Measure & Improve
Tools for measuring improvement and evaluating impact provide visibility into what’s working and what needs improvement among every role, team, and location.
Features:
Hiring Velocity
Hiring Funnel
Hiring Steps
Sourcing Performance
User Activity
New
Feature Placeholder
AI
“I need consistency across locations without more red tape.”
Easy-to-adopt tools that fit with existing flows drive the transition from scattered to standardized.
"I need to surface the best candidates quickly — before we lose them."
Hireology helps you identify top candidates early in the process, and gives your team the tools to evaluate and act fast, without cutting corners.
"I need more right-fits, not just more resumes."
By building a hiring portfolio from multiple sources, and optimizing it in real time, Hireology helps to ensure optimal alignment between candidate skills and job requirements.
"I need control over how we manage resources, timelines, and outcomes."
Hireology gives you the tools to create structure, enforce consistency, and stay informed – all without needing to personally manage every step.
"I need candidates who actually show up, stick around, and succeed."
Hireology helps to raise the bar at every stage, attracting stronger candidates, evaluating for long-term fit, and supporting a better start.
"I need accountability so hiring doesn't fall through the cracks."
By easily assigning roles and tracking activity, Hireology makes it easy to enforce timelines, and keep everyone on track.
"I need visibility into what's working, what's not, and where things stall."
Hireology helps you see across every role, team, and location, so you can take action with confidence, knowing what’s working, what’s not, and what’s getting in the way of hiring momentum.
"I need fewer unfilled positions — those are revenue-killers."
Fast access to the right fits and accountability built into process flows helps to keep your teams fully staffed and productive.
"I need to make it simple for managers who are
on the go.
"
Recruitment tools that easily integrate into day-to-day realities of the job, help managers to hire well, without dropping what matters most.
“I need to make applying fast and easy.”
A fast, mobile-friendly, low-friction application experience helps to keep job seekers engaged from the first click to the final step.
Automotive
Dealership department heads are on-the-go, not at a desk. Hireology offers purpose-built retail automotive solutions that provide speed and structure for smarter staffing.
Healthcare
With an expert focus on the realities of healthcare staffing, Hireology helps teams to move efficiently to build a pipeline of qualified, committed care providers across all facilities.
Hospitality
Hireology’s hiring service-centric hiring solutions for hospitality helps managers to move fast, stay consistent, and staff smarter.